Thinking of raising your insurance excess to save cash? Read this first.
23 November 2026
Reading time: 6 minutes
By Tom Hartmann,
0 comments
Lifting your excess is one way to keep rising premiums from getting out of hand, but comparing providers and switching can save you even more.
Insurance premiums keep doing their thing (creeping up), so it’s no surprise more of us are turning up the excess dial. I found some time to talk with Justin Lim, whose team runs the insurance comparison site Quashed, to help us all figure out if dialling up the excess is the best option. (Sorted doesn't receive or pay anything for talking to the experts or looking at the data.)
His latest round shows the excess people choose is up 18% on a year ago. “Excess is one effective way to keep premiums from increasing or slow the increase, but the average savings is 5–10% ($60–$120),” Justin told me.
The short of it is, raising your excess can trim your premium, but it also shifts more of the risk onto you. Here’s how to work out whether it’s the right move.
Excess, explained
What exactly is an insurance excess? When something goes pear-shaped and you make an insurance claim for a payout, your excess is the amount you pay towards the claim before your insurer covers the rest. Choose a $1000 excess and make a $4000 claim, and you’ll pay the first $1000. Your insurer pays the other $3000.
So a higher excess means you agree to cover more of the cost of smaller mishaps yourself. In return, your insurer charges you less. Some policies have more than one excess even.
How much could you actually save?
Not as much as you’d like, perhaps. Moving your car excess from $500 to $750 saves around 5%, and going to $1000 saves about 10%. On a $1200 car policy, that’s $60 to $120 a year. Spread higher excesses across several cars plus your house and contents, and the saving could top $500 a year. That’s still something!
The saving can be much bigger if you combine changes. In one scenario, for example, comprehensive cover for a 2020 Toyota Corolla dropped from $1258 to $673 a year, a 46% saving. That happened after the excess was raised from $500 to $1500 and the sum insured was trimmed from $24,000 to $22,000 to reflect the car’s current value.
Saving vs risk: how much is the trade-off?
It helps to weigh your yearly saving against what you’d pay if you claimed.
Take that earlier example. Raising your car excess from $500 to $1000 on a $1200 policy saves around $120 a year. But it leaves you $500 more out of pocket each time you claim, so you’d need to go about four years without a claim just to break even.
If you claim often, or a surprise bill would push you onto a credit card, the saving may not be worth it.
Ramp up the excess? Or stay low?
It comes down to your emergency fund. “If you have savings that can cover a higher excess, this is a good way to reduce your premiums,” says Justin. If you don’t, a lower excess is the safer choice for now.
“Traditionally, we see insurance shoppers defaulting to a $500 excess for car insurance, $250 for contents insurance, and $500 for house insurance,” says Justin.
But plenty of New Zealanders are now going higher:
- The most common car excess is still $500 (roughly half of car owners choose it), but $1500 and $2000 excesses have jumped 52% and 51% in the past year.
- For contents, $500 is now the most common (up from $250 in 2024).
- For house insurance, $1000 has overtaken $500, and $5000 excesses are up 466%. That’s driven partly by high premiums in places like Wellington.
Build your buffer
Not there yet? If you don’t yet have savings that will cover a higher excess, your next step is building your emergency savings. Our free Sorted Buffer builder™ app can help you make it happen.
5 Q’s before you raise your excess
- Can you pay it tomorrow? Your excess should come from savings you can reach quickly, not from debt.
- Is your sum insured right? Cars lose value, so one worth $30,000 may be worth $10,000–$12,000 seven years later. Contents, on the other hand, can grow after Black Friday and Christmas. Adjust up or down.
- Are you paying twice? Drop add-ons you already have elsewhere, like roadside assistance if you’re an Automobile Association member.
- Does your cover still fit? If you’ve rented out your home, for example, you’ll need a landlord policy.
- How are you paying? Paying fortnightly or monthly usually costs about 10% more than paying once a year. That’s an average of $127 extra on a car policy, yet more than half of under-40s don’t realise it. Some insurers don’t charge more for instalments, so check when you compare.
Shop around beforehand
A higher excess is one way to slow rising premiums, but comparing providers usually saves more. The Quashed Insurance Index shows average savings of $379 on car insurance, $364 on contents and $893 on house insurance when people shop around. And 8 in 10 find savings on their car policy.
Why do prices vary so much? “While it can sound too good to be true, for a comprehensive car policy, one insurer may quote you $2000 and another may be $1000,” says Justin. “Insurance companies price for the risk they want to and can take on.”
If an insurer already covers lots of a particular car model or homes in a flood-prone suburb, it may push prices up. So last year’s cheapest option can become this year’s most expensive. Justin recommends comparing at least four options, and their Quashed Market Scan can help you quickly compare insurance quotes from multiple insurers.
You don’t have to wait for renewal either. You can switch any time and get a refund for the unused part of your premium. Just make sure your new cover starts before you cancel the old one.
How often should you review this?
“Your excess selection is not a one and done,” says Justin. “Review this yearly when you’re checking on your insurance.”
Don’t leave it longer than two or three years, and check it whenever your life changes. As your emergency fund grows, you may be able to go higher. If your savings take a hit, it could be time to bring it back down.
Not sure your savings could cover a higher excess? Start building your emergency fund today, so you’re ready when the time is right.
Comments (0)
Comments
No one has commented on this page yet.
RSS feed for comments on this page | RSS feed for all comments